Big Brother Watch study replicates pioneering research by Crocels’s Jonathan Bishop

Big Brother Watch study replicates pioneering research by Crocels’s Jonathan Bishop

A comprehensive data report published by civil liberties group Big Brother Watch has inadvertently replicated and validated over a decade of pioneering digital speech research conducted by Jonathan Bishop, founder of the Centre for Research into Online Communities and E-Learning Systems (Crocels).

The new findings, which expose a staggering 62,199 police arrests for online communication offences over a five-year period, provide real-world proof of structural flaws first mapped by Bishop in the early 2010s. Both datasets paint a stark portrait of a legal system failing to distinguish between genuine, malicious harassment and everyday online “noise”.

The Big Brother Watch data reveals that between 2021 and 2026, UK police forces arrested tens of thousands of citizens under Section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 and Section 1 of the Malicious Communications Act 1988. Of those arrested, only 18,150 individuals were charged and 12,292 were convicted—meaning nearly 80% of arrests did not result in a conviction.

This massive drop-off directly mirrors the core arguments found in Bishop’s landmark Digital Teens and the ‘Antisocial Network’ studies. Writing extensively on the phenomenon of internet trolling, Bishop warned that treating the digital ecosystem with sweeping criminal statutes would lead to vast legal inefficiencies.

The data proves His early hypothesis that the UK legal apparatus is sweeping up thousands of ordinary citizens for casual messages, jokes, or heated political remarks, rather than isolating malicious digital actors.

A key finding of the recent Big Brother Watch report is the extreme regional variation in how digital laws are enforced, revealing that some provincial police forces arrest individuals at rates 14 times higher than others for identical online behaviour.

This regional disparity directly replicates Bishop’s early academic findings regarding the highly subjective nature of “grossly offensive” speech codes. Bishop previously argued that without standardised definitions, enforcement becomes a postcode lottery heavily influenced by shifting local policing priorities and media-driven “moral panics”.

The structural chaos highlighted by Big Brother Watch is precisely what Bishop sought to prevent with the creation of His Trolling Magnitude Scale (TMS).  Developed through Crocels, the TMS was designed as a proactive matrix for law enforcement. It sought to categorize online behavior into four distinct tiers ranging from minor trolling/flaming to major trolling/abuse.

Despite knowing of the TMS, because UK authorities failed to adopt a standardised, objective framework, police forces have instead spent five years acting as arbiters of online etiquette.

The alignment between Bishop’s academic warnings and Big Brother Watch’s data comes at a critical juncture for civil liberties in the UK. Activists note that the implementation of the controversial Online Safety Act 2023 is poised to exacerbate these issues by shifting enforcement into automated “age-gating” and algorithmic content policing.

“Social media platforms have formally become judge and jury over our speech,” Big Brother Watch noted in an evaluation of the legislative landscape, echoing Bishop’s long-standing concerns over the “corporate censorship” of internet users.

As the fallout from the 62,000-arrest milestone continues, legal scholars and civil liberties advocates are calling for a complete overhaul of how digital speech is policed—demanding a return to the objective, harm-focused thresholds that academic researchers like Bishop have championed for over a decade.

Related Post