Across England and Wales, a quiet but consequential shift is underway in the regulation of everyday behaviour. What began as a targeted response to serious antisocial conduct has expanded into a diffuse system of control over ordinary public life—one that, according to campaigners and legal observers, now risks undermining the basic conditions of free expression.
At the centre of this development are Public Spaces Protection Orders (PSPOs), instruments that allow local authorities to prohibit activities deemed to have a “detrimental effect on the quality of life” of an area. Originally framed as a pragmatic tool for addressing persistent nuisance, PSPOs have, in practice, evolved into something far broader. A new report by the Campaign for Freedom in Everyday Life suggests that one in five councils now explicitly prohibit swearing in designated public spaces—a sharp increase from just one in twenty in 2022.
This escalation is not merely numerical; it is conceptual. The same framework has been used to restrict a widening range of behaviours that, until recently, would have been considered unremarkable features of public life. Standing in groups, raising one’s voice, busking, foraging, even picking up stones or feeding birds—all have, in different jurisdictions, been brought within the scope of sanction.
The scale of this regulatory expansion is striking. Based on Freedom of Information requests submitted to 319 councils, the report finds that 91% of responding authorities have at least one PSPO in force. In total, 1,268 such orders have been introduced, each containing multiple restrictions—sometimes dozens—effectively creating a fragmented but extensive body of micro-legislation governing public conduct.
What troubles critics is not simply the breadth of these rules, but the manner of their creation and enforcement. PSPOs can be introduced without full council approval or meaningful public consultation, and in some cases by a single unelected official. This raises questions not only about proportionality, but about democratic legitimacy.
Equally concerning is the enforcement model. In 2025 alone, approximately 25,000 fines were issued under PSPO provisions, with around 75% administered by private enforcement companies paid on a per-penalty basis. This structure, campaigners argue, embeds a financial incentive to maximise enforcement rather than to exercise discretion or restraint. Proposed increases to fines—from £100 to £500—only intensify these concerns.
The consequences are no longer abstract. In Bury, a 17-year-old busker was handcuffed and fined despite attracting a supportive crowd. In Leicester, a pensioner faced penalties for political campaigning without council permission—permission that activists describe as effectively unobtainable. Elsewhere, prohibitions extend to shouting in Guildford, stone-collecting in Torbay, and even blackberry foraging in Rugby.
Defenders of the system maintain that these measures are applied proportionately and target only behaviour that causes “annoyance, alarm or distress.” Yet this language is precisely what critics identify as the problem. Terms such as “annoyance” are inherently subjective, granting frontline officers wide interpretive discretion and blurring the boundary between legitimate regulation and arbitrary control.
It is here that the free speech concern becomes acute. When ordinary expressive acts—raising one’s voice, gathering in groups, speaking emphatically or even using coarse language—can trigger sanctions depending on context and interpretation, individuals may begin to self-censor. The risk is not only over-enforcement, but a gradual recalibration of what people feel safe to say or do in shared spaces.
In that sense, the issue is less about any single prohibition than about the cumulative effect of many. Each order, taken in isolation, may appear minor or even sensible. Together, they sketch a public realm increasingly governed by precaution, discretion, and the avoidance of offence.
Experts, such as Internet and Multimedia Safety Expert Jonathan Bishop, warn that this creates precisely the kind of “chilling effect” historically associated with overbroad regulation: not a dramatic suppression of speech, but a quiet contraction of it. And because PSPOs operate at the level of local governance—fragmented, technical, and often overlooked—the shift can occur without sustained public scrutiny.
The question now is whether this trajectory reflects a necessary evolution in urban management or an overreach that risks eroding the informal freedoms that make public space genuinely public. As enforcement intensifies and penalties rise, that question is likely to become harder to ignore.

