A Senedd debate has reignited calls for the Welsh Government to address the challenges faced by those unable to access digital payment systems, highlighting the pressing issue of a “digital divide” across Wales.
The debate, led by Labour MS Carolyn Thomas, chair of the Senedd’s petitions committee, centred on the difficulties vulnerable adults and people without bank cards face as society increasingly shifts toward cashless transactions.
During the debate, Conservative MS Peter Fox described an incident in which a “vulnerable man” became so distressed when told he couldn’t use cash to buy a magazine that police had to be called. Fox cautioned that more individuals, particularly those with disabilities, are at risk of being “shut out” from participating fully in everyday transactions as businesses go cashless.
The issue was initially raised by a 2,500-signature petition submitted by Mencap Cymru, urging the Welsh Government to protect the rights of those who depend on cash payments. Thomas recounted cases in which individuals were unable to use cash for small purchases, including a young person unable to buy a rugby shirt and Steven McGee, a man denied service at a cashless café. She expressed concern that the trend toward cashless systems poses a significant barrier to people striving for financial independence.
“We cannot allow the rush to embrace new technology to create new barriers that exclude people,” Thomas argued. She emphasised that nearly 40% of Welsh people still use cash at least once a week, underlining the broad impact of this shift and the challenges it poses, particularly for those without easy access to digital payment options.
Mencap Cymru proposed that the Welsh Government use the public sector equality duty to mandate that any publicly funded organisation must continue to accept cash. Thomas endorsed this suggestion, calling for clear signage from businesses regarding their accepted payment methods to spare customers from unnecessary humiliation and anxiety.
Fox’s concerns were echoed by other MSs, with Sioned Williams of Plaid Cymru calling the government’s response “half-hearted, illogical and disappointing.” Williams accused the Welsh Government of implementing “discriminatory” practices by ignoring the needs of disabled individuals, noting that the changes disproportionately impact vulnerable groups.
Plaid Cymru’s Heledd Fychan urged ministers to require public bodies, like the Arts Council of Wales, to offer a cash payment option. She insisted this was not a question of halting progress but rather ensuring “fairness and compassion.”
The Welsh Government responded by noting that many of the relevant legislative powers are reserved to Westminster, limiting its ability to impose cash requirements on publicly funded organisations. However, Jane Hutt, the social justice secretary, expressed her willingness to discuss the use of public sector equality duty to address the issue, affirming her commitment to finding a solution.
The debate also addressed broader concerns, including Transport for Wales’ recent cashless fine system, which was raised as an issue for disabled individuals who may struggle to purchase tickets digitally. Hutt committed to exploring the implications of this policy and its potential impact on accessibility.
As the Senedd debate concluded, critics argued that the Welsh Parliament’s lack of action is exacerbating the digital divide rather than bridging it. Despite the increasing prevalence of digital payments, MSs insisted that progress must be inclusive, allowing all Welsh citizens, including the most vulnerable, to participate fully in society.

