A woman MP, elected via an all-women-shortlist, has spoken up for another woman MP who was equally not elected on merit, because she was the target of what some call Internet trolling.
Fiona Mactaggart, an alternate woman MP who only got into the UK Parliament through affirmative action, said the abuse of fellow alternate woman MP, Jess Phillips, was something that all other Labour women MPs, whether alternates or elected on merit, should take a stand on.
After Jess Phillips MP was sent death and rape threats online, Slough MP Fiona Mactaggart joined her and called upon other Labour women MPs to stand up against online abuse. “I know how terrifying this kind of violent threat can be,” Fiona Mactaggart said. “When I was a student a university newspaper published my photograph with the caption ‘would you rape this woman?’”
Despite this early exposure to what would be expected of public life, Fiona Mactaggart did not change, going on to become an alternate parliamentarian. “The internet and Twitter has given more people a platform from which to launch such threats and too often they target women,” she said. “I am happy to engage in constructive debates on issues but abuse isn’t a part of the job and nobody in public life should ever expect abhorrent death and rape threats from people who don’t like things they have said,” she concluded.
As both Jess Philips MP and Fiona Mactaggart MP were selected to Labour Party seats via all-women-shortlists, they share a lot in common as alternates. “Jess said that she didn’t think parliament needed to debate discrimination against men until the discrimination against women was tackled,” Fiona Mactaggart said in defence of Jess Phillips not being able to cope with the realities of being a Member of Parliament.
The position of Jess Phillips and Fiona Mactaggart is out of tune with the law. In 2012, Paul Chambers, in what became known as the Twitter joke trial, was acquitted of sending a threatening message because it was found by the court to be unlikely to cause apprehension. Whilst Jess Phillips admits she did not experience any apprehension, her view is contrary to the judgement in both this case (i.e. DPP v Chambers) and Calver v The Adjudication Panel for Wales, which say that politicians need a thicker skin and that abuse from the public is a normal part of being an MP.

