In a recent legal battle, Crocels Community Media Group, known as “Crocels,” found itself in the spotlight as it sought to attain charitable status and registration as a Charitable Incorporated Organisation (CIO) under the Charities Act 2011. The charity watchdog, the Charity Commission, took issue with Crocels’ objectives, contending that they did not exclusively serve charitable purposes for the public benefit.
The case, which unfolded in the Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery), centered around three fundamental objectives presented by Crocels: improving international relations, advancing peace, and innovating for the reduction of standing armies, all in the name of public benefit. However, the Charity Commission’s refusal to grant charitable status stemmed from doubts regarding the charitable nature of these objectives, despite their alignment with the descriptions of charitable purposes in the Act.
The First-tier Tribunal, presided over by Principal Judge McKenna, along with Ms. Elizabeth and Ms. Park, took on the task of reviewing the Charity Commission’s decision. The Tribunal had the critical responsibility of “considering afresh” the registration application. It focused its scrutiny on whether Crocels’ objectives met the legal definition of “charitable purpose” as defined in Section 3(1) of the Act, with a particular emphasis on serving the public benefit.
The Tribunal, highlighting that this issue was a matter of law, carefully dissected each of Crocels’ objectives. Firstly, concerning “improving fraternity between nations,” the Tribunal adhered to established precedent, drawing from the Anglo Swedish Society v IRC (1931) 47 TLR 295 case. In this historic judgment, promoting international friendship or understanding was deemed non-charitable. The Tribunal firmly rejected arguments suggesting that subsequent legislation had rendered this precedent obsolete.
Regarding the second objective, “advancing the understanding and promoting the cause of peace,” the Tribunal considered it a distinct purpose, separate from the recognized charitable purpose of advancing conflict resolution, as defined in the Act. Citing Slade J’s decision in McGovern v Attorney General [1982] Ch 321, the Tribunal concluded that Crocels’ purpose blended a potentially charitable aspect, which involved advancing education on the subject of peace, with a political purpose aimed at influencing Government policy by promoting a cause.
As for the third objective, “innovating for the abolition or reduction of standing armies,” the Tribunal unequivocally classified it as a political purpose since it inherently involved efforts to influence Government policy. Notably, the Tribunal highlighted that Crocels possessed an express power to attempt to persuade politicians and other decision-makers to adopt the charity’s values and policies, further underscoring its political nature.
With these decisive determinations on the issue of charitable purpose, the Tribunal did not delve into the question of public benefit or other matters raised by the Appellant. Ultimately, Judge McKenna refused permission to appeal on 3 August 2016, marking the end of a contentious legal battle for Crocels Community Media Group.

