Brynawel House Alcohol and Drug Rehabilitation Centre Ltd, a key residential facility for alcohol and drug dependency treatment near Llanharan in Rhondda Cynon Taff, has been hit with sharp criticisms from the Care Inspectorate Wales (CIW) over governance breakdowns, unsafe staff recruitment, and lapses in supervision.
The unannounced inspection on March 10, 2020 – the first under the new Regulation and Inspection of Social Care Wales Act 2016 – uncovered multiple breaches of legal requirements, though inspectors noted no immediate harm to residents and that management was already addressing some issues.
Inspectors laid the blame squarely on recent changes in governance and management, which left the service without proper oversight. The report details failures in Responsible Individual (RI) visits, quality assurance reporting, timely notifications to CIW, monitoring of incidents and accidents, complaints auditing, and updating key documents like the Statement of Purpose and policies. Carol Daly, recently registered as RI, and the new Social Care Wales-registered manager were credited with starting improvements, but the lapses stemmed from “absences and changes in leadership” that compromised compliance across the board.
One of the most serious failings was in staff recruitment, breaching Regulation 35 on fitness to work. Files reviewed by CIW were missing critical documents like full employment histories, two references, contracts, photo ID, and DBS checks – with one staff member starting before their DBS was even received. Staff supervision also violated Regulation 36, as not all received quarterly meetings to reflect on performance and get support, though training was deemed adequate and staff spoke positively of the new leadership.
Beyond admin issues, the report flagged medication practices not following best standards, including failure to record reasons and outcomes for PRN (as-needed) drugs, daily temperature checks in storage areas, and admission stock counts. Risk assessments overlooked residents’ abilities in emergencies and handling cleaning products, while infection control slipped with unlidded bins lacking liners, and some hazardous substances were accessible without proper COSHH assessments. Emergency procedure inductions lacked documentation, and Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans (PEEPs) were not universally assessed.
CIW issued no formal non-compliance notices, opting to monitor fixes at the next inspection, and recommended tweaks like Legionella checks and better PRN logging. Brynawel has been operating since 1977 and has faced much scrutinity and criticism. A third of Brynawel’s clients will make a recovery. Another third will relapse. The final third will die young. One service user, Caroline Hewings, said “Treated like a child, get accused of using whilst in there, don’t rate it at all.”
Sue Gwyn, speaking on behalf of Brynawel, said: “Sometimes in the community, you work with people who are a bit ambivalent about changing their drug use or not interested in changing the drug use or not interested in recovery. We’re not having those conversations.“

