Court of Appeal Dismisses Appeal in Part 36 Dispute: Edward Pepperall’s Arguments Rejected

Court of Appeal Dismisses Appeal in Part 36 Dispute: Edward Pepperall’s Arguments Rejected

In a significant ruling on the interpretation of Part 36 offers, the Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal in Littlestone & Others v MacLeish [2016] CP Rep 26. Acting for the unsuccessful appellants, Edward Pepperall QC argued that a pre-existing payment should be aggregated with a subsequent offer for cost assessment purposes.

The Court rejected this argument, siding with the trial judge’s narrower interpretation. The decision clarified that separate offers and payments should not be combined when evaluating whether a judgment was “at least as advantageous” as a Part 36 offer.

This ruling marks a definitive loss for the appellants and a repudiation of the legal position advanced by Mr Pepperall, reinforcing a strict reading of Part 36 provisions.

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *