In a notable move that exposes the harrowing intersection of sports and online racism, Manchester United defender Harry Maguire has publicly urged social media platforms Twitter and Instagram to institute more robust mechanisms for combating the racist abuse targeting athletes. This call for action was prompted by the egregious racial abuse directed at Maguire’s teammate, Paul Pogba, following his missed penalty in a match against Wolverhampton Wanderers.

Maguire took to Twitter, articulating a sentiment shared by many athletes and public figures: “Disgusting. Social media need to do something about it… Every account that is opened should be verified by a passport/driving license. Stop these pathetic trolls making numerous accounts to abuse people.” The sentiment encapsulates the urgency with which social media platforms need to reevaluate their content moderation policies, particularly as they pertain to hate speech and discrimination.
Marcus Rashford, another Manchester United player, reinforced Maguire’s stance. Rashford admonished the racist trolls and reaffirmed the sense of family within the team: “Enough now. This needs to stop. Manchester United is a family. Paul Pogba is a huge part of that family. You attack him; you attack us all.”
Manchester United subsequently released an official statement condemning the racial abuse directed at Pogba. The statement noted that such incidents are entirely incongruent with the values of the club and its supporters, and assured that the strongest possible measures would be taken against those responsible for the abuse. The club’s statement also encouraged social media companies to adopt more effective ways of preventing such incidents.
The abuse incident came after Pogba’s missed penalty during the second half of a 1-1 draw against Wolves. The miss led to a heated discussion with Rashford about who should take future penalty kicks for the team, further fueling the controversy surrounding the incident.
Internet trolling expert, Jonathan Bishop, said the legal system was already able to deal with the matter. “The Public Order Act 1986 can be used to prosecute people who post racist tweets and it has been in the past,” he said. “Twitter is a service provider, and the Equality Act 2010 can be used for racial discrimination,” he continued. “Finally, the Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations 2002 can be used to enforce Twitter’s community rules.”
The case of Paul Pogba and the subsequent calls for action exemplify an increasingly urgent dilemma for social media platforms: the necessity of establishing effective barriers against hate speech and abuse without curtailing free expression. What remains clear is that the laissez-faire approach currently employed is increasingly viewed as inadequate, sparking calls for a more rigorous policy framework that combines technological measures with substantive human oversight. The sustained attention on this issue, not just from the world of sports but also from wider society, adds momentum to the growing demand for reform in the digital sphere.

