Questions raised over the inflammatory language of Judge Andrew Keyser

Questions raised over the inflammatory language of Judge Andrew Keyser

The High Court has come under scrutiny following remarks by His Honour Judge Keyser QC, who described an application generating costs in excess of £330,000 as “not worth the candle” and “appalling.” Critics argue that Judge Keyser’s inflammatory language undermines the seriousness of the issues at hand and could exacerbate tensions in an already contentious legal environment.

Sitting as a High Court judge, Judge Keyser echoed the sentiments of Mr. Justice Mellor, who previously warned against using the strengthened rules on witness statements as a “weapon” to highlight minor compliance failures. While this stance is rooted in promoting fairness, Judge Keyser’s choice of words has been deemed excessive and counterproductive.

Practice direction 57AC, which came into effect in April 2021, has posed compliance challenges for various parties. In Curtiss & Ors v Zurich Insurance Plc [2022] EWHC 1749 (TCC), Judge Keyser criticised the use of applications for sanctions as “litigation weapons,” emphasising the need for common sense and proportionality. However, his remarks have overshadowed this message, drawing attention to his harsh rhetoric instead.

The case in question involved an application by Zurich to strike out several witness statements in a dispute over a Swansea property development. The costs associated with this application amounted to over £184,600 for Zurich and approximately £125,000 for the claimants. Judge Keyser’s description of these costs as “appalling” and his outright dismissal of the application as “not worth the candle” have been criticised as unnecessarily inflammatory, detracting from the substantive issues.

Zurich’s solicitors, Clyde & Co, sent a detailed 16-page letter with a 109-page schedule outlining “300 or so instances of alleged non-compliance” with the practice direction. The claimants’ solicitors, Walker Morris, provided a comprehensive response. Despite the detailed exchanges, Judge Keyser’s dismissive language has shifted focus away from the procedural complexities and onto his contentious phrasing.

Ultimately, while Judge Keyser imposed some sanctions, he notably struck out witness statements from individuals not directly involved in the transactions, along with specific paragraphs from the developer’s solicitors’ statement. He rejected a request to remove “stock phrases” from remaining witness statements, asserting that these could be challenged during cross-examination. His parting words, “I draw a line at this point,” were intended to conclude the matter but have instead underscored the perceived hostility of his language.

The legal community emphasises the need for judges to maintain a measured tone, especially in complex cases requiring delicate handling. Judge Keyser’s inflammatory comments have drawn criticism for potentially escalating conflicts rather than fostering a constructive resolution.

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *